Unacceptable: Apple Health Sync is now behind a $99/year paywall for new accounts

General Discussion
Answered

Comments

  • Adam Q
    5

    likes

    Utterly ridiculous, I’m grandfathered in, but have had Withings devices for a decade - this is the line for me. When my current devices need replacing, or this company starts to penny pinch further, I’ll be looking elsewhere.

    Thoroughly disappointed in Withings and management’s actions.

    5

    likes

  • Walter O
    4

    likes

    Yep agreed. I don’t do SaaS, it’s a predatory business practice that really needs to be shut down. I was going to buy a new withings scale and BP cuff, but my old account is no longer active and I now am stuck behind a paywall for basic HealthKit integration. I can’t support predatory business practices like this and will purchase different equipment due to withings predatory decision.

    4

    likes

  • Dennis Z
    2

    likes

    Fuck of Withings and reverse this. Btw my account is way older than 13 October and sync doesn’t work anymore.

    2

    likes

  • D H
    5

    likes

    Seems they took a horrible turn. Will look for alternatives if this is not reversed.

    5

    likes

  • Baptiste M
    4

    likes

    The more I think about it, the more I feel that this decision makes no sense.

    Vincent Brand says, “This is a decision to prepare for our future.” He also adds that “the value lies in the data.” Our data.

    If the value really lies in our data, and if they were genuinely disruptive, they could have taken a completely different approach to their business model.

    For example, alongside their traditional offering, they could have made syncing with Apple Health free while introducing an alternative subscription model that includes the hardware, say over a 24-month period.

    Essentially, solving one more problem for customers instead of creating another one.

    Instead, they’ve diminished the value of their hardware, their services, and their entire ecosystem.

    But as I’ve said before, all good things must come to an end.

    4

    likes

  • Huanyuan H
    6

    likes

    As someone who had my Withings scale delivered on 13 October, created my account that very same day, and only subsequently found out about this change, I have to say this is truly disappointing.

    This is certainly not the kind of experience I’d expect from a brand positioning itself as a premium health-tech company.

    6

    likes

  • mike
    6

    likes

    I am grateful a friend warned me about this before I became a Withings customer. I am now looking forward to buying a Garmin Index S2 body scale instead.

    6

    likes

  • hello
    5

    likes

    The hardware is fine. Paying $99/yr to sync data I already generated is the part that stings. Once a device has your sleep history, the subscription stops being a feature and starts being leverage. Genuinely curious how many people cancel vs. just grumble and pay.

    5

    likes

  • Michael L
    6

    likes

    I had planned to give my wife a Withings watch for Christmas. But I won’t be doing that. 10 EUR per month is simply outrageous.

    6

    likes

  • Remco v
    9

    likes

    Withings, your response is far from reassuring, and frankly, it fails to address the fundamental issue.

     

    How can you expect existing customers to continue recommending your products when one of their key selling points, seamless Apple Health integration, is now being placed behind a $99 annual subscription

     

    The entire purpose of purchasing a smart scale is to automatically collect, synchronize, and use personal health data across the platforms of our choice. It is our data, generated by devices we have already paid a premium to own. Customers deliberately chose your significantly more expensive smart scales over conventional alternatives because of features such as Apple Health integration.

     

    Suggesting manual data exports as an alternative completely misses the point. That is effectively the digital equivalent of telling customers to write their measurements down on paper. It defeats the very purpose of owning a connected smart device.

     

    Furthermore, your reassurance that existing account holders will remain unaffected is misleading. What happens if an existing customer needs to create a new account, migrate to a different account, or reset their setup? Suddenly, functionality that was included when the product was purchased becomes subject to a recurring subscription fee.

     

    This is not an acceptable way to treat loyal, long-standing customers. Changing the conditions surrounding core functionality after customers have already invested in your hardware seriously undermines trust in your brand.

     

    What makes this particularly frustrating is that Apple Health integration relies on functionality already provided by iOS. It is not inherently a premium cloud service requiring ongoing infrastructure from Withings. Charging $99 annually simply to synchronize personal health data with Apple Health is extremely difficult to justify. It also raises legitimate questions about compliance with Apple’s policies concerning HealthKit data and monetization.

     

    You are turning a fundamental product feature into a recurring revenue stream at the expense of customer trust.

     

    Unless this decision is reversed, I will no longer purchase or recommend Withings products. I will actively look for alternatives from manufacturers that respect data ownership and provide Apple Health integration without imposing additional subscription fees.

     

    I strongly urge Withings to reconsider this decision, restore unrestricted Apple Health synchronization, and honor the functionality customers reasonably expected when purchasing your devices.

     

    Customers should not have to pay an annual fee to access and synchronize their own health data from hardware they already own.

    9

    likes

  • dvan_buuren
    8

    likes

    I was going to ask for a Withings watch for Christmas but will be seeking out another watch due to this change.

    8

    likes

  • h4d3sz
    7

    likes

    I was ready to buy the Body Scan 2 as you were the prime option recommended for your Samsung Health partnership, but pulling this move on users is disgusting. I'm happy and sad at the same time; I was really looking forward to testing your new tech and seeing how well it works and evolves, but not after this. I'm glad the model was delayed in my country and this surfaced before I bought any of your products.

    7

    likes

  • Keziah G
    7

    likes

    To Marcus from Withings : Since you say that Withings is ‘closely following the active discussions’ regarding their decision to put automatic syncing to third party apps behind a paywall, I am staggered that they are completely ignoring the HUGE number of people who have decided not to buy Withings products they fully intended to purchase. Also the equally huge number of their formerly loyal customers, many of whom recommended Withings products to family and friends. Plus the many who no longer intend to give Withings products as Christmas gifts.

    25 days into this very active discussion, how long does Withings need to realise the damage this is doing to its reputation, its customer base and present and future sales? Do they have the wisdom and humility to reverse this decision, or are they just going to ignore what is going on, at their peril?

    7

    likes

  • Sergej J
    7

    likes

    If you read the official interview they have done on Numerama as well as this large discussion of the same on Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/withings/s/5ZhEhy2PQT


    It is painfully clear they will not revert on this decision. They are seemingly in financial issues due to general LLMs providing more value so they are betting on keeping users by forcing them onto subscriptions.

     

    They consider any data provided by devices to be THEIRS instead of ours as customers.

     

    And they have made poor bet on the AI features so they are basically now doubling down on this (even if it means less customers), in hopes of pulling the revenue up for the intermediate period (selling subscriptions is still much cheaper than selling devices).

     

    I do think in the long run this will backfire significantly as;

    1. More customers will switch to other companies but realistically most of these happen over longer period, you don’t uograde these devices yearly so long term customer impact will be only felt in year, two or three.

    2. The downturn in sales will only be felt as more and more new customers figure out that they have been entraped into their ecosystem upon purchases (visible by the return of devices, which again will most likely only happen after BlackFriday/Christmas periods).

    3. And PR damage beyond the initial outrage that earned them news about subscription showing above the product pages, will be again primarily visible once future reviewers call out the subscription as serious downside to these products which will knock down their otherwise quite high product scores. As people realise these are not one tiem purchases, rather 100$/year subscriptions on top of already steep prices, they will have less sales.

     

    Since financial upturn of forcing subscriptions is imminent and all the consequences are all mid to long term, I would not expect there to be any change on this decision.

     

    The sad part is by when they do feel the impact, it will be way too late. Trust will have erroded on the loyal customers doing the big part on “selling a good product through recommendations” to their family and friends because they are happy with it. And by focusing on subscription/AI features that costs as much as models (OAI, Claude) but for the same price offer way less they are in uphill battle.

     

    This will also take away from investement into hardware which is and was the primary selling point for last decade. So competition will also get to catch up (as witnessed by proliferation of other scales with simialr features over last few years).

     

    So I would expect in upcoming years to have at best, again Nokia style situation with another company taking them over for data and IP once they lose enough customers.

     

    Again, on personal level really sad to see as I still think these are some of the best devices on hardware level. On the other hand once management changes the mission from “empowering people with health data”, to “squeezing the profit by locking down our data”, I really can’t in good judgement say that it will be sad to see them fail.

    7

    likes

  • Dan W
    5

    likes

    I’m disgusted by this move. My phone died and i set up a new Withings account with my new phone. Now my step count doesn’t sync with Apple health anymore. Regardless my situation anyone buying a smartwatch expects their data to sync with Apple health, least of all step count. Forcing your customers to pay a significant annual fee for this is a cynical money grab by Withings, I’ll never buy one of your devices again after this.

    5

    likes

  • Valerio V
    5

    likes

    I'm not convinced the impact of this decision will be mid to long term only. If I were a new customer, I would select another company for sure for my new scale (or return it if I already bought it) the minute I find out this is missing a basic feature that everyone else is offering for free!

    I expect an impact even on new devices, and it's a pity, since they just refreshed their hardware lineup, and their new scales are excellent!

    5

    likes

  • Larry B
    4

    likes

    • 1.) If you already have a Withings account, nothing changes. If you created your account on or before October 12, 2026, automatic third-party sync stays free. This is tied to your account, not your device, so buying a new scale, watch or any other Withings device in the future won’t affect it. Your sync stays free.

     

    I've had my account for years and it hasn't sync'd since 10/30!!

    4

    likes

  • Nicolas C
    5

    likes

    @Markus From Withings, can you guarantee that Apple Health synchronisation will remain free for existing users as long as we keep our current accounts—even when replacing our devices or disconnecting and reconnecting Apple Health?

    I was about to upgrade both my Withings scale and blood pressure monitor, but I need a clear commitment on this before making a purchase. Without that assurance, I would consider alternatives rather than invest in new Withings products.

     
    5

    likes

  • Nick T
    5

    likes

    Never again Withings products. Such greedy decisions to make money.

    5

    likes

  • Andrew T
    5

    likes

    The irony of all this is that the Withings+ product has been improving so much that I was thinking of subscribing and paying the annual fee anyway, but this move makes me lose all faith in the company. I won’t give them a dollar or a euro more as long as they are so hostile to customers. It’s sad that the company has so little confidence in their own ability to develop attractive products that they have to base their business strategy on extorting customers.

    5

    likes

  • Johnston B
    4

    likes

    This is a tacky cash-grab. I'm glad to be grandfathered in, but I won't be recommending Withings products to people anymore. (I've probably helped sell 30 scales in the years since I bought my first scale.) How about increasing revenue by being innovative so we buy more of your products instead of putting your hands into people's pockets looking for spare change? Charging a subscription to use a product you've paid for when all you're doing is pushing data around is such a lazy way to make money. 

    4

    likes

  • Levente K
    4

    likes

    I seriously reconsider any Withings purchases after this move. Put the sync onto Apple Health is absolutely unacceptable.

    4

    likes

  • Logan H
    5

    likes

    Woah! As a former employee and active user since 2019, my access no longer works. I opened a support ticket, but if this is a way to just drive users to Withings+, I fear it’ll have the opposite effect. Sadly I’m considering finding an alternative hybrid smartwatch. 😢

    5

    likes

  • jblae
    4

    likes

    Sry but this is a unacceptable business practice. Sad to see a company go down like this

    4

    likes

  • Lior L
    3

    likes


    This is an outrageous decision. I will return or sell my newly purchased scale and find an alternative that connects to Apple Health without a $100 US annual subscription! 

    I wish I had known before I bought my scale; I never would have bought it in the first place. I am never buying any of their products again unless they reverse this decision. 

     

    3

    likes

  • Baptiste M
    2

    likes

    @ lior L

    Unfortunately, selling it might not be that easy either, considering the annual subscription fee required to use it with Apple Health. This decision seriously undermines its resale value.

    2

    likes

  • Paul K
    2

    likes

    It makes no sense to paywall syncing.

    My wife tried to set up an app that needed her weight to sync.

    She has used my withing scale for years but it made her split off a new account to set this up and here we are getting gouged.

    The price of a year subscription is the same as buying another scale from another brand... With 0 added value from what we paid for in the first place. After 2 years not paying for subscription it pays for a high end scale, like say a Garmin, that still lets multiple users sync.

    Looks like we are shopping for a new scale sadly. :(. It was a good product. RIP.

    2

    likes

  • Matkus K
    1

    likes

    I created a second user for our household AFTER 13th Oct, so that means the first user can sync, but my other family member can't?

    That is crazy :( Will get different brand then. 

    1

    likes

  • tim b
    1

    likes

    Its time each of you do more than register your polite complaints. Backup your data, delete your account and move on. Its been over a month and they have posted no more than their geralized and scanty response that never dealt with the issue at hand: Making people pay to see their own data.

    Please, leave Withings - they don't care about you and though you may be reading these posts, Withings is not. They aim to ride this out. Fine, they will do so without me and any hope of further purchases or good word of mouth.

    THAT speaks louder than these messages

     

    Best to each of you.

     

    1

    likes

  • withings.escapade781
    1

    likes

    I have been waiting for half a year to order several products from your website, and I was about to order them today until I learn about the awful decision you made and the fact that I will not be having automatic Apple Health sync. I am sorry, but paying 250 euro for the scales and not having this basic feature is a deal breaker and completely no go for me. 

    It is sad you chose this tactic because both you and me will suffer from it. Hope you will reconsider some day, but until then I will buy from a competitor.

    1

    likes

Leave a comment as